Exercise set
Solid-Liquid Separation, Crystallization, Drying, and Cake Handling Exercises
Solved solid-liquid separation exercises for filtration, cake moisture, centrifuge recovery, crystallization yield, drying duty, solvent removal and release gates.
These exercises focus on separations where solids, crystals, cakes or wet product must be recovered and released. They cover filtration rate, filter area, cake moisture, wash displacement, centrifuge recovery, crystallization yield, mother-liquor loss, dryer solvent removal, drying duty, residual solvent, solids handling capacity and release evidence.
Assume simplified screening calculations unless an exercise states otherwise. Real design must check particle size, crystal habit, compressible cake behavior, wash efficiency, centrifuge limits, dust hazard, solvent flammability, dryer oxygen control, product assay, containment and waste route.
Release Evidence Notes
Solid-liquid separation evidence should state slurry feed, solids concentration, filtrate quality, cake mass, cake moisture, wash basis, recovery, fines loss and equipment state.
Crystallization evidence should state solubility basis, yield, impurity rejection, seed or nucleation control, mother-liquor recycle and product assay.
Drying evidence should state wet-cake basis, solvent or water removed, heat duty, vapor handling, residual solvent, oxygen or inerting controls, dust controls and product release rule.
Engineering Boundary Notes
These calculations do not replace pilot filtration tests, centrifuge vendor sizing, crystallization kinetics, dryer hazard analysis, solvent LEL review, dust explosibility testing or product-quality validation. They are screening exercises for solids release.
Common Release Mistakes
- reporting dry solids recovery while ignoring liquid retained in cake;
- assuming wash displacement is perfect;
- counting crystallized product while losing product in mother liquor;
- drying to average moisture while local wet pockets remain;
- releasing dried solids without residual solvent, dust and vapor-handling evidence.
Scenario Map
| Scenario | Exercises | Primary check | Engineering decision |
|---|---|---|---|
| Filtration and cake | 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 | slurry solids, area, cake moisture, wash and filtrate loss | Decide whether filter operation is releasable. |
| Crystallization and centrifuge | 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 | yield, mother liquor, centrifuge recovery, fines and purity | Decide whether product recovery is credible. |
| Drying and handling | 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17 | solvent removal, heat duty, residual solvent, capacity and evidence | Decide whether dried product or residue can be released. |
| Release gate | 18 | all-of solids release | Decide whether the package can close. |
Exercise 1: Slurry Solids Feed
A slurry feed is 12\ \text{m}^3/\text{h} at density 1150\ \text{kg/m}^3 and 18\% solids by mass. Compute dry solids feed.
Solution
Slurry mass flow:
Dry solids:
Engineering Comment
Filter, centrifuge and dryer sizing should start from dry solids and liquid load, not only slurry volume.
Plausibility Check
Eighteen percent of about fourteen tonnes per hour is about two and a half tonnes per hour.
Exercise 2: Filter Area From Flux
Required filtrate flow is 9.5\ \text{m}^3/\text{h}. Sustainable filtrate flux is 0.38\ \text{m}^3/\text{m}^2\text{/h}. Compute filter area.
Solution
Engineering Comment
Sustainable flux should come from process slurry tests, not clear-liquid data.
Plausibility Check
About ten cubic meters per hour at less than half a cubic meter per square meter-hour requires about twenty-five square meters.
Exercise 3: Cake Moisture
Wet cake is 3600\ \text{kg/h} and dry solids are 2484\ \text{kg/h}. Compute cake moisture by wet mass.
Solution
Liquid in cake:
Moisture:
Engineering Comment
Cake moisture sets dryer load, solvent loss and handling behavior.
Plausibility Check
About one third of the wet cake mass is liquid.
Exercise 4: Cake Wash Displacement
Cake contains 1116\ \text{kg/h} liquid with 2.5\% impurity. Washing displaces 70\% of retained liquid. Compute impurity remaining in cake liquid.
Solution
Initial impurity:
Remaining after wash:
Engineering Comment
Wash efficiency should be validated with product assay, not assumed from wash volume alone.
Plausibility Check
Thirty percent of about twenty-eight kilograms per hour remains.
Exercise 5: Filtrate Product Loss
Filtrate flow is 9.5\ \text{m}^3/\text{h} and dissolved product concentration is 0.18\ \text{kg/m}^3. Compute product loss to filtrate.
Solution
Engineering Comment
Filtrate loss may justify recycle, polishing or crystallization changes if product value is high.
Plausibility Check
Low concentration over about ten cubic meters per hour gives a few kilograms per hour or less.
Exercise 6: Crystallization Yield
A crystallizer feed contains 520\ \text{kg} dissolved product. Product crystals recovered are 410\ \text{kg}. Compute yield.
Solution
Engineering Comment
Yield should be checked with mother-liquor assay and crystal purity.
Plausibility Check
Four hundred ten is a little under eighty percent of five hundred twenty.
Exercise 7: Mother-Liquor Product Loss
Mother liquor volume is 4.2\ \text{m}^3 and dissolved product concentration is 18\ \text{kg/m}^3. Compute product remaining in mother liquor.
Solution
Engineering Comment
Mother-liquor recycle can recover product but may build impurities.
Plausibility Check
Several cubic meters at tens of kilograms per cubic meter gives tens of kilograms.
Exercise 8: Crystal Purity
Dry crystal product is 410\ \text{kg} with 6.5\ \text{kg} impurity. Compute purity.
Solution
Engineering Comment
Purity alone does not prove release if yield, solvent, moisture or impurity trend fails.
Plausibility Check
Impurity is small relative to product mass, so purity is high.
Exercise 9: Centrifuge Solids Recovery
Centrifuge feed contains 2484\ \text{kg/h} solids. Solids lost in centrate are 86\ \text{kg/h}. Compute solids recovery.
Solution
Engineering Comment
Recovery must be balanced against cake moisture, fines loss and downstream drying load.
Plausibility Check
Losing less than one hundred kilograms out of about twenty-five hundred gives high recovery.
Exercise 10: Fines Loss Fraction
Total solids loss is 86\ \text{kg/h}. Fines below specification account for 52\ \text{kg/h}. Compute fines share of solids loss.
Solution
Engineering Comment
If fines dominate loss, particle-size control or flocculation may be more effective than more centrifuge speed.
Plausibility Check
Fifty-two is a little over half of eighty-six.
Exercise 11: Dryer Solvent Removal
Wet cake feed to a dryer is 3600\ \text{kg/h} at 31\% liquid. Product target is 5\% liquid by wet mass. Dry solids are 2484\ \text{kg/h}. Compute final wet product mass and liquid removed.
Solution
Final wet product mass:
Final liquid:
Initial liquid:
Removed liquid:
Engineering Comment
Dryer vapor handling and condenser or abatement capacity should be sized on removed liquid.
Plausibility Check
The dryer removes most but not all retained liquid.
Exercise 12: Dryer Heat Duty
Liquid removal is 985\ \text{kg/h} and effective latent heat is 2300\ \text{kJ/kg}. Estimate heat duty.
Solution
Engineering Comment
This excludes sensible heat, losses and inefficiency, so real utility demand will be higher.
Plausibility Check
About one tonne per hour of evaporation requires hundreds of kilowatts.
Exercise 13: Residual Solvent Limit
Dried product is 2615\ \text{kg/h} and residual solvent is 0.18\% by mass. Product release limit is 0.25\%. Compute margin.
Solution
Engineering Comment
Residual solvent must be tied to sampling method and batch uniformity.
Plausibility Check
The result is below the limit with less than one third of the limit remaining as margin.
Exercise 14: Dryer Vapor Abatement Load
Solvent removed is 985\ \text{kg/h}. Condenser captures 92\%. Compute solvent sent to downstream abatement.
Solution
Engineering Comment
Drying release needs vapor handling evidence, especially for flammable or toxic solvent.
Plausibility Check
Eight percent of about one thousand kilograms per hour is about eighty kilograms per hour.
Exercise 15: Solids Handling Capacity
Dry product conveyor capacity is 3000\ \text{kg/h}. Final wet product flow is 2615\ \text{kg/h}. Compute handling margin.
Solution
Engineering Comment
Handling margin should include bulk density, stickiness, dust and surge behavior.
Plausibility Check
The conveyor capacity is only a few hundred kilograms per hour above product flow.
Exercise 16: Batch Evidence Completion
A solids release package requires slurry feed, solids assay, filtrate assay, cake moisture, wash record, centrifuge loss, mother-liquor assay, dryer temperature, residual solvent, vapor abatement, product assay and packaging hold status. Nine of twelve records are complete. Compute completion.
Solution
Engineering Comment
The package is not release-ready if missing records include residual solvent, product assay or vapor abatement.
Plausibility Check
Nine of twelve is three quarters.
Exercise 17: Dryer Safety RPN
A high-solvent dryer discharge failure has severity 8, occurrence 4 and detection 5. Compute RPN.
Solution
Engineering Comment
The score supports interlocks, oxygen control, validated sampling or hold-and-test release.
Plausibility Check
Moderate-high ratings multiply to a three-digit value.
Exercise 18: Solids Release Gate
A release gate requires crystal purity above 98\%, centrifuge recovery above 95\%, residual solvent below 0.25\%, handling margin above 10\%, and evidence completion above 90\%. Current values are purity 98.4\%, recovery 96.5\%, residual solvent 0.18\%, handling margin 14.7\% and completion 75\%. Decide release status.
Solution
Purity, recovery, residual solvent and handling margin pass. Evidence completion fails:
Release status:
Engineering Comment
Product quality appears acceptable, but release should wait until batch and safety evidence is complete.
Plausibility Check
An all-of release gate fails when documentation and safety evidence are incomplete.
Validation Package Checklist
- Slurry, filtrate, cake, crystals, mother liquor, dryer vapor and product streams close a mass balance.
- Cake moisture, wash, centrifuge recovery and fines loss are measured on the same batch basis.
- Drying calculations include removed liquid, duty, vapor abatement and residual solvent.
- Product release separates purity, moisture, solvent, handling and evidence gates.